I’m celebrating my 20th year of writing about sales, networking, loyalty, trust, attitude, leadership, business social media and personal development.
My core of information transformed into a body of work that includes 11 books – all bestsellers. I did it while you were watching TV. I chose to write instead of watch.
-Jeffrey Gittomer
Due this Thursday, 10/18
900-1200 words minimum (3-4 pages). 3 cited sources MINIMUM. MLA Format.
What tracking methods are available for media?
TV, Radio, Print, Online
Crown said it will now a receive a full subscription to Rentrak’s television measurement services, which employ feedback from digital set-top boxes in 19 million American homes. According to Ed Georger, Crown Media Holdings’ executive VP of advertising sales, the move puts his company closer to day in which it sells its commercial time based on metrics other than Nielsen’s.
“We’re in the early stages of doing that,” he told us. “There’s a lot we still need to explore.”
The move to arbitrate the price of advertising with an additional ratings data source comes after high-profile voices in the TV industry — most notably, Viacom (NYSE: VIA) CEO Philippe Dauman — have leveled concerns regarding Nielsen’s methodology, which uses a much smaller sample of 25,000 homes. Nielsen drew contention from Dauman when it reported year-over-year viewership drops of more than 20 percent for Viacom’s Nickelodeon kids channel in the fourth quarter.
However, a report comparing Nielsen and Rentrak measurement of Nick’s November performance revealed significant discrepancies. For example, Nielsen reported a whopping 22.6 percent viewership drop for the channel’s Monday-Friday lineup, while Rentrak said it was only around 12.7 percent.
Blogged BTIG Research analyst Richard Greenfield: “Beyond illustrating that Viacom, and more importantly, Philippe Dauman are not crazy, the more important takeaway from the data discussed above is that content creators, ad buyers and brands should all be utilizing multiple data sources versus simply buying ad time solely on Nielsen metrics alone.”
Nielsen is facing pressure from other research companies besides Rentrak. Last month, NBCUniversal (NSDQ: CMCSA) commissioned Google and comScore to develop a multi-platform audience measurement tool for the Olympics that would follow viewers across the full range of usage devices.
The 2012 London Games, which run for two weeks starting July 27, will be the third consecutive Olympics in which NBCU will conduct this kind of research. With the company offering its coverage across many platforms over a finite period of time, the Games typically provide an optimal test subject to conduct research on new metrics, NBCU officials say.
This time, however, the company is approaching the development of a so-called “single-source” metric with a little more urgency. Powerful voices within the TV industry are calling for an overhaul of the current ratings system, which lacks tools to measure audiences across platforms.
At the Consumer Electronics Show last month, Warner Bros. (NYSE: TWX) TV Group president and TV Academy chairman Bruce Rosenblum struck an industry chord when he equated the current ratings system to living in the “dark ages” and said it was “embarrassing” to the business. Having conducted experiments for the 2008 Beijing and 2010 Vancouver Games with tiny panels of 60 viewers or less, NBCU’s research this time around will feature much bigger audience samples.
Google plans to create a panel of about 3,000 consumers, using a meter-based system to track viewership across platforms. Google will also create algorithms specifically designed to measure this usage.
ComScore, meanwhile, will cull 750 Olympics enthusiasts from the 10,000-member audience panel it developed with AT&T (NYSE: T) AdWorks. Viewership data from this group will be compiled from a combination of AT&T U-verse set-top boxes, electronic meters and the self-reporting by panelist.
NBCU will not aim to create a true national sample with this research, but rather a proof of concept that shows the broadcast and advertising industries that such single-source metrics can indeed be created. “Cross-platform measurement is extraordinarily challenging, but we believe the unique and complimentary nature of these research projects will bring us one step closer to cracking the code of single-source measurement,” NBCUniversal research president Alan Wurtzel said in a statement.
NBCU has coined its research the “Olympics Billion Dollar Lab,” a reference to the $2.2 billion its shelling out to license London Games coverage across its broadcast, cable, Internet and mobile platforms. It has not announced programming plans across its various platforms yet. But it has confirmed that it will offer more than the 835 hours of coverage it offered for the 2010 Vancouver Olympics.
Company Calls Nielsen Ratings Pay-to-Play
Click here to read Courthouse News' Entertainment Law Digest. New Delhi Television Ltd. sued Nielsen and a slew of other defendants, including Nielsen's alleged former competitor, Kantar Media Research, and the J. Walter Thompson ad agency, in a 194-page complaint in New York County Supreme Court.
New Delhi Television (NDTV) claims the ratings agencies displayed "unabashed short-term greed and reckless disregard of its duties and of its noble origin. It is a case of the two largest audience measurement conglomerates in the world, Nielsen and Kantar, formerly competitors, operating worldwide through a deliberately complex web of subsidiaries and joint ventures, creating, at least in India, a monopoly and abusing the power of that monopoly."
The complaint continues: "This is also a case of the Nielsen Board of Directors, as proxies for the world's largest and most powerful group of corporate takeover specialists (referred to herein and in Nielsen's 2011 Annual Report as 'Sponsors') that, since 2006, control Nielsen, recklessly disregarding, in New York City, the worldwide operating headquarters of Nielsen, their explicit responsibilities to customers under the Dutch laws to which they are subject, the country of Nielsen's incorporation being the Netherlands.
"The sponsors consist of KKR, The Blackstone Group, The Carlyle Group, Thomas H. Lee Partners, Alpinvest Partners, Hellman & Friedman and Centerview Partners."
The Sponsors are not named as defendants.
The complaint continues: "Cost cutting and cost avoidance measures to maintain revenues are the basic tenet of leveraged buyouts. For example, The Blackstone Group's 2011 Annual Report explicitly acknowledges that 'highly leveraged entities are inherently more sensitive to declines in revenues'. The cost cutting and cost avoidance measures adopted by Nielsen are the direct result of the Nielsen Directors and [defendant Nielsen CEO] David Calhoun acting solely in their own short term interests and the short term interests of the sponsors, while disregarding their explicit obligations to thousands of customers such as NDTV. The sponsors benefit from such cost cutting measures in the short term, during which short term they have commenced, since January 2011, to 'cash out' their controlling interest in Nielsen and/or otherwise siphon resources from Nielsen.
"The sponsors, through the Nielsen Directors and David Calhoun, order cost cutting and cost avoidance measures to maintain share prices in the short term, so they can 'cash out,' as part of the typical leveraged buyout 'exit strategy,' making billions of dollars in profits.
"The sponsors have already begun such process. As of January 2011, they owned 100 percent of Nielsen. As of March 2012, they own 66 percent.
"Thousands of Nielsen's customers, such as NDTV, are the victims of such cost cutting measures. "Nielsen's wrongdoings, including, but not limited to, negligence, gross negligence, false representations, prima facie tort and negligence per se (based on violations of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act and the Dutch Corporate Governance Code), have had catastrophic effects on customers, on the television industry, on advertisers and on and viewers in the US and overseas."
NDTV claims the ratings agencies negligently allowed violations of the Foreign Corrupt Practices Act by creating the entity Television Audience Measurement, or TAM, to implement ratings in the Indian market. NDTV says it learned about the corruption of TAM from an unidentified "consultant."
"The consultant stated that the corruption involving TAM is so widespread that he decided to become a whistle blower," the complaint states.
NDTV it met the consultant this year at a Feb. 28 meeting with Nielsen representatives at the J. W. Marriott Hotel in Mumbai.
"At the said meeting, the representatives of Nielsen interrogated the consultant as to how the bribes were paid and who was/were the person(s) responsible for taking bribes on behalf of TAM to fix ratings. The consultant named several employees of TAM who took bribes through other consultants to fix ratings for channels," the complaint states.
NDTV claims it learned more about ratings corruption during an April 3 meeting at Mumbai's Ramada Plaza hotel with two field staff employees of TAM.
"[The TAM staffers] claimed to have effected manipulations in the past for other channels and were willing provide the same 'services' for 'any' channel that was ready to pay the demanded consideration (bribe)," the complaint states. "They were confident that they could triple channel ratings of NDTV in Mumbai over a period of two to three weeks in the required target group. They stated they had direct access to homes and visited those homes periodically (at least 3 to 4 times a week) and were in a position to easily influence what the households watched/viewed. They said by paying a bribe of US $250 to US $500 per household per month, the TAM households could be made to watch only those channels which they insisted upon."
Nielsen isn't illegal monopoly, judge rules
U.S. District Judge Paul C. Huck ruled Thursday that while some of Nielsen's practices might be anti-competitive, WSVN's owner Sunbeam Television failed to prove that the Nielsen Company was blocking any "willing and able competitor'' from the TV-ratings business.
Huck's summary judgment dismissing accusations that Nielsen violated federal and state laws strips Sunbeam's 2009 lawsuit of the potential to trigger revolutionary changes in the television business. The two companies are still submitting arguments on other counts in the lawsuit that accuse Nielsen of breach of contract and deceptive business practices.
Sunbeam officials said they will appeal the dismissal of the anti-trust portion of the lawsuit.
Nielsen's ratings, which measure TV audiences and determine how much advertisers pay for commercials, are the bedrock of the industry, affecting nearly every business decision and most of the creative ones, too. Sunbeam's lawsuit sent shockwaves throughout the industry when it was filed in Miami in April 2009.
The suit was triggered by Nielsen's decision to change the way it counts television audiences. Instead of asking viewers to write down the names of programs they watched in little paper diaries, the company equipped sample homes with so-called people meters: set-top boxes that recorded what channel was being viewed, with each household member clicking buttons to register who was actually watching.
When the people meters were introduced in South Florida in October 2008, they produced wildly different results than the paper diaries had. Cable-network ratings soared and broadcast-channel ratings plummeted. WSVN's numbers dropped by nearly half in some time slots.
Sunbeam's lawsuit called the new ratings results "obviously -- and dramatically -- defective," costing it $1 million a month in advertising revenue. "As a result of its monopoly, Nielsen is able to charge supracompetive prices for poor quality services," the lawsuit said.
But Huck's 23-page ruling said that Sunbeam didn't offer any evidence that there's a better way to compile TV ratings than with people meters -- or, "more importantly, that such ratings would benefit Sunbeam."
And while some Nielsen business practices, including the timing of its contracts with TV stations, might discourage competition, Huck ruled, Sunbeam failed to show that any other company was interested in providing local TV ratings.
"Though there is evidence of exclusionary contracting practices'' by Nielsen, the judge wrote, "Sunbeam has not established the existence of a ‘willing and able' competitor," as required by anti-trust law.
What Determines Primetime TV Ad Prices? A Reader Runs The Numbers
Categories: TV Advertising
As much as I'd like to think of myself as a numbers guy, my education is so far in the past that I've forgotten 90% of what I think I once knew. Not so with reader Brendan, he's in the thick of it right now and produced a backward looking analysis of what factors seem to determine advertising prices for primetime broadcast shows. While it will appeal to only a fraction of our readers, for them it may make their day.
Here is his summary, but you can read his entire paper here. The text below is all from Brendan:
I love poring over the yearly Advertising Age survey that estimates the cost of a 30 second advertisement for each primetime show. So I did a statistical analysis on what factors influenced these estimated ad prices for the 2009-2010 season.I examined The Following factors for 65 returning shows:
- total viewers (2008-2009 seasonal average in ratings points)
- 18-49 viewers (2008-2009 seasonal average in ratings points)
- age skew (the ratio of 18-49 viewers to total viewers)
- affluent viewers (whether or not the show was among the top ten “upscale series with highest indices” according to a recent MediaPost article)
- day of the week (when the show airs)
- network (where the show airs)
- timeslot (what time the show airs)
- scripted (whether the show is scripted or unscripted)
- DVR viewers (whether or not the show had one of the top twenty 18-49 demo increases due to DVR)
I concluded that The Following combination of factors best explain the ad cost for a given show:
the amount of 18-49 viewers,
how young the show skews,
the affluence of the viewers,
whether the show is scripted or unscripted,
and whether or not the show airs during the 10:00 hour.
The other factors (notably DVR viewers) did not seem to have a significant effect.
18-49 viewers
If you visit the site often, it should be obvious that ad cost would be mostly determined by how many 18-49 viewers the show can attract each week. Advertisers seem willing to pay about $50,000 for each demo point. This factor effectively sets a “base price” for ad costs, while other factors may be worth paying a little more for.
Age skew
Advertisers also seem to favor shows that skew young, as an advertisement on a show with a higher percentage of 18-49 viewers will cost more. From the data, it appears that shows with more total viewers tend to skew older, so I believe this just indicates that the most efficient way to reach 18-49 year olds is to advertise on shows that skew young.
Affluent viewers
The application of the data I obtained to evaluate affluence is dubious, but the results correspond with intuition. Essentially, an advertisement on a show with a more upscale audience is pricier than a comparable show with less affluent audience (by about $10,000).
Scripted or unscripted
Likewise, advertising time for a scripted show is pricier than that of a comparable unscripted show (by about $10,000). My best guess is that this is an indication of a higher viewer engagement with scripted shows.
10:00 PM time slot
The data suggests that a show that airs at 10:00 PM will earn more than a comparable show in another time slot (about $5000-$10,000 more). This confused me at first, but I do have a (perhaps tenuous) hypothesis as to why this might be. If advertising buyers predicted low ratings from The Jay Leno Show and thus decreased competition in the time slot five nights a week, they may have expected 10:00 shows on the other networks to benefit from increased ratings. This is a bit of a reach, so I welcome any better explanations.
This study was fairly simple, and not particularly rigorous, so I would not recommend reading too much into it. Having said that, I do think it is safe to base estimates of the value of a show almost entirely on 18-49 ratings and that (at least for this season) each 18-49 ratings point is worth about $50,000 per 30 second ad.
Methods
I used gretl, a statistical software package, to create and evaluate various linear regression models. The final concluded model is a weighted least squares regression that attempts to account for heteroskedasticity given by:
Ad Cost = -68.22 + 47.63(18-49 Viewers) + 0.91(Age Skew) + 10.81(Affluent Viewers) + 12.73(Scripted) + 7.53(10:00 Timeslot)
Why does The North Coast Journal publish on Thursday?
What's the effect of commercially driven media on our viewing choices? How does it affect the news? How do our tracking methodologies inform the type of content we receive?
Why does content type vary by text type?
18-49 viewers
If you visit the site often, it should be obvious that ad cost would be mostly determined by how many 18-49 viewers the show can attract each week. Advertisers seem willing to pay about $50,000 for each demo point. This factor effectively sets a “base price” for ad costs, while other factors may be worth paying a little more for.
Age skew
Advertisers also seem to favor shows that skew young, as an advertisement on a show with a higher percentage of 18-49 viewers will cost more. From the data, it appears that shows with more total viewers tend to skew older, so I believe this just indicates that the most efficient way to reach 18-49 year olds is to advertise on shows that skew young.
Affluent viewers
The application of the data I obtained to evaluate affluence is dubious, but the results correspond with intuition. Essentially, an advertisement on a show with a more upscale audience is pricier than a comparable show with less affluent audience (by about $10,000).
Scripted or unscripted
Likewise, advertising time for a scripted show is pricier than that of a comparable unscripted show (by about $10,000). My best guess is that this is an indication of a higher viewer engagement with scripted shows.
10:00 PM time slot
The data suggests that a show that airs at 10:00 PM will earn more than a comparable show in another time slot (about $5000-$10,000 more). This confused me at first, but I do have a (perhaps tenuous) hypothesis as to why this might be. If advertising buyers predicted low ratings from The Jay Leno Show and thus decreased competition in the time slot five nights a week, they may have expected 10:00 shows on the other networks to benefit from increased ratings. This is a bit of a reach, so I welcome any better explanations.
This study was fairly simple, and not particularly rigorous, so I would not recommend reading too much into it. Having said that, I do think it is safe to base estimates of the value of a show almost entirely on 18-49 ratings and that (at least for this season) each 18-49 ratings point is worth about $50,000 per 30 second ad.
Methods
I used gretl, a statistical software package, to create and evaluate various linear regression models. The final concluded model is a weighted least squares regression that attempts to account for heteroskedasticity given by:
Ad Cost = -68.22 + 47.63(18-49 Viewers) + 0.91(Age Skew) + 10.81(Affluent Viewers) + 12.73(Scripted) + 7.53(10:00 Timeslot)
Slick ad campaigns now are affordable to small firms
Hard times in ad and media industries are creating bargains for small businesses seeking higher profiles. A Redondo Beach diner is among those taking advantage of lower production costs and ad rates.
A cable television commercial for the Redondo Beach restaurant Eat at Joe's features high-definition video, a cast of 40 and a catchy jingle that will leave you humming.
Particularly enthusiastic about the slick new ad was Alex Jordan, the restaurateur who decided to take the plunge into television advertising after meeting an Altadena couple who were starting their own ad agency. They wrote and produced the 30-second spot for $5,000, and they helped him broker a deal to deliver it to 300,000 homes for $1 every time it ran.
FOR THE RECORD:
Advertising: An article in Wednesday's Business section about small business and the cost of advertising said the average cost to air a 30-second commercial on network TV was $921. It should have said that $921 was the average cost to air a 30-second ad on a network-affiliated TV station in a major media market. —
In a still tough economy in Southern California, hard times in advertising and media have led to a surprising bonanza for small businesses seeking to market themselves. Across all media, the cost of developing marketing campaigns, creating ads and placing them is down — making marketing more affordable than it's ever been.
At the same time, as smaller businesses test the advertising waters, they're providing much-needed work for start-up production companies and graphics artists, and filling space at TV stations, on billboards and in other media that would otherwise go unsold.
Bill Burnett and Debrah Lemattre, an entertainment industry couple struggling through a slow period, shot the Eat at Joe's spot with a digital camera and edited it at home. They set up all the shots in one day and cast it with actors willing to work for free.
Verizon Communications, eager for advertisers on its FiOS TV service, which is sent through telephone lines to about 300,000 subscribing households in Southern California, charged a buck a pop.
According to the American Assn. of Advertising Agencies, a typical 30-second television commercial costs about $130,000 to make. "Eat at Joe's," with 20 shots and 40 actors, would have cost about $200,000 several years ago, Burnett estimated.
But the economic downturn has made the process cheaper at every turn. Producers will work for less, advertisers are charging less, and businesses — burned by the recession but needing to reach out to new customers — are paying less.
Nationwide, the average cost to air a 30-second spot on network TV was $921 last year, down from $1,109 the year before, according to Nielsen Co. Spots on cable stations, always significantly cheaper than networks, were also down, experts said.
As a result, many mom-and-pop businesses can afford a level of advertising that was previously beyond their reach. Some are embracing the opportunity, hoping that visibility on TV, billboards and the Internet will help them recover from tough times.
"Smaller clients can definitely get more for less now," said Michael Knott, senior vice president and media director for West Coast operations of the advertising agency Draftfcb. "There's more of a willingness of vendors to work with you … offering lower rates and more value for your money."
Jordan said the TV ad — his first — boosted business at the diner by about 10%. It worked so well, he said, that he's planning to expand the commercial's reach by showing it on the larger Time Warner Cable system starting next month, paying $5 to $15 per showing depending on the time of day.
"I was a little nervous," Jordan said. "I didn't want it to be cheesy. But it turned out really well."
Nationwide, the cost of producing a TV spot dropped about 5% in 2008, the most recent year for which the American Assn. of Advertising Agencies has figures. The reduction was largely the result of decreases in the length of time used for shooting and the salaries paid to the director, actors and producers.
The advertising market is beginning to recover after a profound slump last year, but experts say it will be some time before prices hit boom-time levels — if they ever do.
As banks, automakers and large retailers reduced their marketing budgets or went out of business during the economic downturn, media companies began to intensify efforts to sell ads to smaller businesses.
Billboard operators offered better placement and promotional rates, while TV stations and cable operators sent salesmen to meet with local businesses that rarely advertised. Newspapers lowered their prices for ads, and graphic designers offered websites for less. Even television networks reached out to smaller businesses, helping them hone pitches to be aired on affiliated stations.
In San Diego, Adios Pest Control decided to advertise on TV for the first time after its owners were approached by representatives of NBC-TV, said co-owner Jeremy Sykes. The pest control company is paying an average of $51 each time the spot airs, and NBC did not charge extra to produce it.
--
--
--
Print Tracking?
http://www.accessabc.com/services/circulation.htm
Radio Tracking?
http://arbitron.mediaroom.com/index.php?s=43&item=841
Billboard Tracking?
http://www.empowermm.com/blog1/out-of-home/new-outdoor-ratings-will-fuel-tremendous-growth-for-outdoor-advertising/
http://www.mediapost.com/publications/article/136102/facebook-how-formats-timing-affect-response.html
What's the effect of commercially driven media on our viewing choices? How does it affect the news? How do our tracking methodologies inform the type of content we receive?
What are the advantages and disadvantages of paid vs. free content?
http://www.courthousenews.com/2012/07/30/48808.htm
http://www.nextlevelofnews.com/2012/03/end-of-a-60-years-ratings-monopoly-nielsen-vs-rentrak.html
http://miamiherald.typepad.com/changing_channels/2011/01/nielsen-isnt-illegal-monopoly-judge-rules.html
http://tvbythenumbers.zap2it.com/2009/12/04/what-determines-primetime-tv-ad-prices-a-reader-runs-the-numbers/35280/
http://articles.latimes.com/2010/jun/01/business/la-fi-cheap-ads-20100602
Does Baby Einstein make you smarter?
$200 million dollar company, playing on the social myths.