Review
Mainstream Media has multiple target groups
What are they?
Semiotics is the study of.....?
SIGNS
Marxist Analysis has a BIG flaw. What is it?
it Begs the Question
Marxist (media) Analysis starts with the answer. What is that answer?
The ruling class (the bourgeoisie) uses the mainstream media to oppress the working class (proletariat) and reinforce their own cultural values to maintain the status quo.
Does the bourgeoisie believe their own messages?
Yes!
And what are they?
Myth of the self made man, American/cultural exceptionalism, meritocracy.
"You didn't build that"
Paul Ryan's Self-Made Myth
In politics and journalism, myth often passes as biography. For evidence, look no further than The New York Times and Washington Post's
profiles of newly minted vice-presidential candidate Paul Ryan, who by
virtue of a few well-deployed anecdotes—told by his brother and by
fellow congressman and confidant Jeff Flake—has been transformed into
the apotheosis of the self-made man. The linchpin of this
pull-yourself-up-by-you-bootstraps story is the death of his father when
Ryan was 16. "It is remarkable that he chose a path of individual
responsibility and maturity rather than letting grief take a different
course," the candidate's brother tells the Times, which elaborates with an encomium worthy of an Anglo-Saxon epic:
You see, while the rest of us welfare recipients sit at home eating Doritos we bought with food stamps, Paul Ryan has been out there catching fish with his bare hands...But if you wipe the stardust from your eyes, you'll be forced to admit that for all his talk about the free market, Ryan has spent precious little time in it and in fact has benefited from government help more than most. When his father died, Ryan received Social Security payments that helped pay for his college tuition. He attended Miami University, a public institution that receives millions of dollars in federal and state money every year. Since then, Ryan has spent most of his life—15 years, to be exact—on the government's payroll. And as opposed to Mitt Romney, who earned his money in private equity, Ryan married into his fortune.
Michelle Obama’s message: President Barack Obama is just like you.
Washington, Sept. 6 (ANI): The notion that the U.S. provides
exceptional opportunities for upward mobility is a myth, a new study has
shown.
According to a University of Michigan researcher, who is studying inequality across generations around the world, "especially in the United States, people underestimate the extent to which your destiny is linked to your background."
Fabian Pfeffer, a sociologist at the U-M Institute for Social Research (ISR), is the organizer of an international conference on inequality across multiple generations being held September 13 and 14 in Ann Arbor.
"Research shows that it's really a myth that the U.S. is a land of exceptional social mobility," he said.
Pfeffer's own research illustrates this point based on data on two generations of families in the U.S. and a comparison of his findings to similar data from Germany and Sweden.
The U.S. data come from the ISR Panel Study of Income Dynamics, a survey of a nationally representative sample that started with 5,000 U.S. families in 1968.
His self-reliance followed him to summer camp, where as a counselor he canoed and hiked, and into young adulthood, where he took up deer hunting. …The Post sings Ryan's virtues in less-poetic terms:
It followed him into college, where he immediately took a passionate interest in the canon of conservative economic theorists and writers. …
It followed him to Congress, where his brand of conservative economics, honed in Washington’s conservative policy and research groups, eventually inspired the Tea Party freshmen in the House for whom Mr. Ryan has served as seer, cheerleader and workout buddy.
And, finally, it captured the imagination of Mitt Romney, who named Mr. Ryan as the Republicans’ presumptive vice-presidential nominee on Saturday.
Ryan’s big ideas bear the stamp of his own story: They stress independence and self-reliance, the qualities that took him from the mailroom to a spot on his party’s presidential ticket. What government owes its citizens, Ryan says, is not a guarantee of happiness—only a fair shot to pursue it. ...I can see it now, a promo for a TV movie: a shot of Paul Ryan standing atop a mountain with a deer flung across his back dissolves into footage of him in a college dorm room, enraptured by Atlas Shrugged while through the window unruly women's rights protesters burn bras. We see a young Ryan working at McDonald's as a teenager, then cut to him running up the steps of the Lincoln Memorial, sweat dripping from his brow. The Star-Spangled Banner crescendos as he reaches the apex. Text flashes across the screen: Paul Ryan, Self-Made Man.
In his private life, Ryan pursues the hobbies of an everyman with an overachiever’s zeal. He sweats through grueling “P90x” workouts in the House gym. He beats other legislators in contests to recite the most lines from “Fletch.” And he fishes for catfish—with his bare hands.
You see, while the rest of us welfare recipients sit at home eating Doritos we bought with food stamps, Paul Ryan has been out there catching fish with his bare hands...But if you wipe the stardust from your eyes, you'll be forced to admit that for all his talk about the free market, Ryan has spent precious little time in it and in fact has benefited from government help more than most. When his father died, Ryan received Social Security payments that helped pay for his college tuition. He attended Miami University, a public institution that receives millions of dollars in federal and state money every year. Since then, Ryan has spent most of his life—15 years, to be exact—on the government's payroll. And as opposed to Mitt Romney, who earned his money in private equity, Ryan married into his fortune.
Michelle Obama’s message: President Barack Obama is just like you.
“Barack knows the American Dream because
he’s lived it,” the first lady told the Democratic National Convention
on Tuesday in an address intended to reassure voters that her husband
share their values — hard work, perseverance and optimism — while also
drawing a contrast between him and Mitt Romney.
Mrs. Obama never mentioned the president’s Republican challenger, who grew up in a world of privilege and wealth.
But the point was clear as she weaved a
tapestry of their early years together, when money was tight and times
were tough, when they were “so in love, and so in debt.” She reminisced
about the man who now occupies the Oval Office pulling his favorite
coffee table out of the trash and wearing dress shoes that were a size
too small. And she told stories about a president who still takes time
to eat dinner with his daughters nearly every night, answering their
questions about the news and strategizing about middle-school
friendships.
With a mix of personal anecdotes and policy talk, Mrs. Obama’s speech was her most political yet.
Michelle Obama speaks during opening night of the Democratic National Convention in Charlotte.
“Today,
after so many struggles and triumphs and moments that have tested my
husband in ways I never could have imagined, I have seen firsthand that
being president doesn’t change who you are — it reveals who you are,”
she said.
To that send, the first lady painted a
portrait of a leader who knows first-hand the struggles of everyday
Americans, who listens to them as president, and who pushes an agenda
with their interests in mind.
“That’s the man I see in those quiet
moments late at night, hunched over his desk, poring over the letters
people have sent him,” she said. “I see the concern in his eyes … and I
hear the determination in his voice as he tells me, ‘You won’t believe
what these folks are going through, Michelle . it’s not right. We’ve got
to keep working to fix this. We’ve got so much more to do.”
She added: “I see how that’s what drives Barack Obama every single day.”
With such stories, the first lady sought
to counter Republicans trying to paint Obama as something other than a
typical American, and implied that it was Romney who couldn’t relate to
people trying to get by in tough economic times.
To be
sure, neither Romney nor Obama fits the bill of the average,
working-class American struggling with credit card debt and mortgage
payments.
The American Dream?
According to a University of Michigan researcher, who is studying inequality across generations around the world, "especially in the United States, people underestimate the extent to which your destiny is linked to your background."
Fabian Pfeffer, a sociologist at the U-M Institute for Social Research (ISR), is the organizer of an international conference on inequality across multiple generations being held September 13 and 14 in Ann Arbor.
"Research shows that it's really a myth that the U.S. is a land of exceptional social mobility," he said.
Pfeffer's own research illustrates this point based on data on two generations of families in the U.S. and a comparison of his findings to similar data from Germany and Sweden.
The U.S. data come from the ISR Panel Study of Income Dynamics, a survey of a nationally representative sample that started with 5,000 U.S. families in 1968.
He
...found that parental wealth plays an important role in whether children
move up or down the socioeconomic ladder in adulthood.
And that
parental wealth has an influence above and beyond the three factors that
sociologists and economists have traditionally considered in research
on social mobility - parental education, income and occupation.
Both are millionaires who live a privileged life few Americans
will ever experience.
President Obama is worth $6 million.
Paul Ryan is worth $5 million.
The mainstream media doesn't decide what you think about the issues, they decide what issues you think about.
Who are we forgetting?
Marxist (media) analysis is not always wrong. Sometimes it is an extremely useful tool for looking at the coded messages sent our way.
Last Class
We discussed the Olympics. Just about as Mainstream as it gets. What examples of racism did we see?
Sexism?
Cultural Superiority?
North Korea's Key to Olympic Medals: Refrigerators For Winners, Labor Camp Threat for Losers
By JOOHEE CHO | ABC News – Fri, Aug 3, 2012
Other Cultures do it too!
Remember, North Korea won some medals, then went for 15 minutes of daily coverage to 5 hours.
Top 5 events covered by NBC, what did they have in common?
Swimming – including Michael Phelps’ quest to become the most decorated Olympian ever – track & field, gymnastics, diving and beach volleyball, among other sports
Top 5 athletes on Twitter--what did they have in common?
The Olympics are a microcosm of mainstream media messages. Commercials are incredibly tightly produced, giving us a great insight into mainstream media messages. Review this Olympics commercial by a major corporation:
Companies like P&G are a force in the world ... [it's] market
capitalization is greater than the GDP of many countries, and... [it] market[s] products in more than 180 countries.
P&G touch[es] lives in small but meaningful ways. Billions of them. Every day.
P&G touch[es] lives in small but meaningful ways. Billions of them. Every day.
The simple, inspiring way to think about this
[] is that P&G brands serve about 4.6 billion of the nearly
seven billion people on the planet today.
P&G is the 27th largest company in America.
Watch
the 'Thank You Mom' spot again. What is your emotional response to this
ad? What is the intent of the advertiser? Provide a Marxist
analysis of this commercial. Is the ad sexist? Patriotic? What cultural
values does it reinforce? Which values does it ignore?
Group Paper Due 9/20. Chapter 3 Quiz 9/20.
Group Presentation 9/20. 50% content, 50% delivery.
Yes, they are the same day. Start working!!!!
Group Presentation 9/20. 50% content, 50% delivery.
Yes, they are the same day. Start working!!!!
Paper is 600-900 words, MLA style. When completed, Rank the top 2 members of your group 1 & 2. They will receive extra credit.
http://prospect.org/article/paul-ryans-self-made-myth
http://www.urbannewsroom.com/2012/09/04/michelle-obama-touts-humble-upbringing-as-she-headlines-night-one-at-the-democratic-convention/
http://www.forbes.com/sites/erincarlyle/2012/05/16/obamas-worth-nearly-6-million-see-why-hes-down-since-last-year/
http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2012/08/14/paul-ryan-worth-millions-_n_1774346.html
http://www.bostonreview.net/BR37.5/ndf_james_heckman_social_mobility.php
http://www.teamusa.org/Olympic-Games/2012/Team-USA-extras/NBC-Broadcast-schedule.aspx
http://www.pg.com/en_US/company/purpose_people/index.shtml
www.london2012.com/medals/

No comments:
Post a Comment